• home
  • our story
  • find a job
  • toolbox
  • events
  • how we can help you
  • get in touch
  • tenders
Menu

comms2point0

Street Address
City, State, Zip
07739 41 23 77
comms2point0.co.uk is a shared learning space, created by – and written for – creative communications professionals

Your Custom Text Here

comms2point0

  • home
  • our story
  • find a job
  • toolbox
  • events
  • how we can help you
  • get in touch
  • tenders

so long to the spin doctors

October 13, 2016 Darren Caveney

Telling the truth. It’s what most comms people want and encourage. A new piece of research decided to look a little deeper into the subject. Here are the results…

by Jon Reeves

After recently completing a CIPR diploma research project on Issue Management, I drew many conclusions. Most notably that Comms professionals are, on the whole, the good guys (and gals).

I wasn’t shocked, it was a result I’d expected but it was still heartening to see.

I picked this subject after being inspired by a press release issued by Mars Foods earlier this year, which highlighted the fact that some of their products – notably Dolmio and Uncle Ben’s sauces – were so unhealthy they should only be consumed occasionally. So I set out to discover whether a more transparent approach to communicating issues would be welcomed by those practising PR.

My survey was answered by 60 Comms professionals, including those working in the public and private sector and featured job roles ranging from apprentice to director. If you were one of them, thank you!

The key findings were that 73% of people were aware of issue management, 71% saw it as either ‘important’ or ‘crucial’ and 78% practised it in their role. An encouraging start.

For the benefit of anybody that would’ve been in the 27% unaware of issue management, it basically covers the identification of potentially harmful issues and uses strategic public relations planning to manage them.  

During the survey, it emerged that while most Comms professionals wanted to be more transparent in the way they communicated issues, significant barriers prevented them from doing so.

Only 57% of people had taken a transparent approach in practice and only 52% of those deemed their actions to have been ‘entirely transparent’. An impressive 76% stated that their approach was successful but only 56% said that it lead to a more transparent approach from their organisation.

People’s views on the Mars press release were quite interesting. Half of those surveyed viewed it as ‘brave, commendable and likely to enhance their reputation in the future’, with 10% perceiving it as ‘risky and likely to damage their brand.’

A quarter of respondents thought that Mars should’ve been even ‘more transparent’ and provided more information to customers and offered healthier products. The remaining 15% had differing views but mostly saw Mars’ actions as positive, regardless of what their motivations might’ve been.

My favourite response here was…

“It depends on whether the information was likely to leak or not. I would suggest they had some kind of intelligence to suggest this was likely to be a media issue at some point in the future so this was managing the risk. If this was the case then it's an approach I would take and I think it is commendable, if not then I'm not so sure.”

Analysing the qualitative data, the emerging theme was that the biggest barrier to a more transparent approach to PR was senior management. Many suggested that those at the top of their organisation would never support such an approach and perceive it to be too risky.

This was fairly predictable but it emphasises just how important it is for comms people to influence decision-making and inspire leaders to be brave, even when faced with challenging situations.

In conclusion, after all that analysis and number crunching, my gut feeling that comms professionals fundamentally want to be open and honest, was upheld.

My findings suggest a widely held belief that addressing issues head on, being transparent and offering solutions is better than working hard to absolve blame or conceal mistakes. So long to the spin doctors. The good guys have taken over.  

Pearls of wisdom

Finally, here are some of the most interesting responses I received which helped my study but also seem like cracking bits of advice…

“PR isn't just about singing the praises of an organisation, there's a need for greater transparency to build trust especially where wishing to engage with citizens and particularly hard to reach groups. Honesty is required to help build links with cynical and detached community groups.”

“Manage the issue, manage the fallout. You still have to be proactive to manage reactive comms. Get the senior buy in early and demand that people give you the information and responses you need to protect their reputation.”

“Genuinely honest messaging has an element of authenticity about it which can easily win people over and create understanding and empathy. It is difficult to get senior management to understand how simple this is, but once they get it they will run with it. It helps to outline a clear approach at the outset and stick to it.”

Jon Reeves is communications advisor at Futures Housing

image via the U.S. National Archives

Print Friendly and PDF
In resources + good stuff, research + evaluation, campaigns + media Tags so long to the spin doctors, pr spin doctors, telling the truth in pr and communications, jon reeves, comms2point0
← 'I'm so proud of my local council' how comms listening to social media led to a significant thing facebook: what happened when we tried a different approach with groups and pages →

sign up for the comms2point0 weekly email

delivered once a week. straight into your inbox. guaranteed to be packed full of good stuff. absolutely no fluff.

comms2point0 will *always* respect your privacy.

Thank you!

Want to write a post for comms2point0?  Email us a brief outline of your post idea or specialist subject and we'll be in touch!

Name *
Name

Thank you, Darren or Dan will be in touch with you soon!

latest events ...
UNAWARDS WINNERS MASTERCLASS
Apr 24
UNAWARDS WINNERS MASTERCLASS

BIRMINGHAM - FREE EVENT

ESSENTIAL VIDEO SKILLS FOR COMMS
May 21
ESSENTIAL VIDEO SKILLS FOR COMMS

LONDON - NEW DATE

SKILLS YOU NEED FOR LIVE VIDEO
May 22
SKILLS YOU NEED FOR LIVE VIDEO

LONDON - NEW DATE 

ESSENTIAL DIGITAL SKILLS FOR COMMS
May 24
ESSENTIAL DIGITAL SKILLS FOR COMMS

LONDON - NEW DATE

ESSENTIAL VIDEO SKILLS FOR COMMS
May 30
ESSENTIAL VIDEO SKILLS FOR COMMS

MANCHESTER - NEW DATE

ESSENTIAL VIDEO SKILLS FOR COMMS
Jun 4
ESSENTIAL VIDEO SKILLS FOR COMMS

BIRMINGHAM - NEW DATE

ESSENTIAL VIDEO SKILLS FOR COMMS
Jun 7
ESSENTIAL VIDEO SKILLS FOR COMMS

EDINBURGH - NEW DATE

ESSENTIAL DIGITAL SKILLS FOR COMMS
Jun 14
ESSENTIAL DIGITAL SKILLS FOR COMMS

BIRMINGHAM - NEW DATE

latest jobs...

Featured
Apr 19, 2018
communications officer (social media & pr), charnwood borough council
Apr 19, 2018
Read More →
Apr 19, 2018
Apr 19, 2018
communications officer, the office for nuclear regulation
Apr 19, 2018
Read More →
Apr 19, 2018
Apr 19, 2018
communications team leader, dorset councils partnership
Apr 19, 2018
Read More →
Apr 19, 2018
Summary Block
This is example content. Double-click here and select a page to feature its content. Learn more
Featured
Latest Article
Related Posts Plugin for WordPress, Blogger...

comms2point0.co.uk is a shared learning space, created by – and written for – creative communications professionals.  Home to fresh comment, informed opinion, in depth analysis and expert feature articles, comms2point.co.uk inspires and supports communications professionals in the UK, Europe and beyond.

©2011 - 2018 comms2point0.

Related Posts Plugin for WordPress, Blogger...