• home
  • comms2point0 interims
  • find a job
  • toolbox
  • events and training
  • mentoring
  • how i can help you
  • get in touch
  • the unawards
Menu

comms2point0

Street Address
City, State, Zip
07739 41 23 77
comms2point0.co.uk is a shared learning space, created by – and written for – creative communications professionals

Your Custom Text Here

comms2point0

  • home
  • comms2point0 interims
  • find a job
  • toolbox
  • events and training
  • mentoring
  • how i can help you
  • get in touch
  • the unawards

snapchat and instagram stories which one is best?

August 9, 2016 Darren Caveney

The new stories feature on Snapchat allows short narratives to be made with images, text and video. Instagram have copied them. One comms person gave them the once-over.

by Albert Freeman

During the 2016 Bradford Festival I experimented with Snapchat Stories to share a behind-the-scenes account of the festival. It was a successful pilot, and I feel that both Snapchat, and Instagram's new Stories feature, have potential for more storytelling by organisations.

Stories on Snapchat or Instagram are an ideal way to capture the spirit of an event, with a chronological narrative of how the event unfolds. Both types of Story are made up of photos and short videos that stay online for 24 hours and then disappear from your Story. So when we used our Snapchat Story at Bradford Festival, at any one point during the festival, followers could see the last 24 hours worth of snaps. Then once the festival had passed, so did our Story.

The ephemeral nature of Snapchat and Instagram Stories makes them ideal for imperfect sharing, where capturing a moment, and telling a story, is more important than quality of shot. The transient content on your Story can help bring an experience to life while your carefully crafted material is shared on your permanent Instagram feed, on Twitter and Facebook.

Snapchat is largely used by young people, and a local cultural festival is an ideal opportunity to reach out to a younger audience. This is why I chose to pilot it at Bradford Festival.

We shared our snapcode on Twitter, Facebook and Instagram in the build up to the festival to publicise our new account. Discoverability of new accounts and audience growth is still a bit of a problem on Snapchat. About 30 people added us that weekend, which wasn't bad given that we had only just announced our new channel. Snapchat will show you who has seen each snap in your Story, and most of those 30 people who added us went on to view our Story, so we had a pretty good engagement rate.

Our Snapchat Story for Bradford Festival included:


  • footage of the stage being set up before the festival started

  • footage from the side of the stage while artists set up gear and while they performed

  • an exclusive video message from a local performer

  • the stage being taken down the day after the festival ended.


Snapchat's stickers and filters add life to your content, with Geofilters helping to localise your snaps. Geofilters are pre-existing graphics or text that you can overlay on top of your snaps. Not only did I find that there are several Geofilters for Bradford, but there is also a Geofilter for City Park, the exact location of Bradford Festival. It is likely that if you use Snapchat you will also find several options for local Geofilters. Perhaps you could also encourage people in your local community to submit Geofilters to Snapchat.

As luck would have it, Snapchat launched its Memories feature in the UK on the weekend of Bradford Festival. This gave me the opportunity to save all of the snaps from our Story within our Snapchat acount, and even save a replica of the story itself. While we can now reshare individual snaps from our Memories, the Story itself now only exists on my phone.

One game changing feature that Memories has introduced is the ability to upload snaps edited elsewhere into a Story. Some organisations have already started to take advantage of this new storytelling method. See for example, BBC News on Snapchat, who have developed Stories specifically edited for Snapchat's vertical display.

One potential problem with Stories is that it is quite a one-way communication, with not much in the way of open engagement. Snapchat does have a feature called Live Stories which broadens the process out from simply broadcast to participation. With Live Stories, everybody at an event can submit a snap to a collaborative Story. To use this feature at local festivals would be brilliant, but unfortunately this feature is only currently available at events Snapchat endorses.

Instagram's Stories is largely a copy of Snapchat Stories, mimicking a lot of its features, although there are some key differences. I've seen Instagram Stories described as 'Snapchat for adults', but I think that's perhaps an oversimplification of what is still largely an untested medium.

It's certainly true that the content you share to each network should be based on what is relevant to each audience. Always consider your own unique audience, whatever the channel. Think about what is relevant to share in a Story, rather than what is technically possible to share, or what you want to share.

Instagram Stories is very intuitive to use. Many people new to Snapchat find they way it works to be unfamiliar and difficult to get used to. Also, the placement of new Stories from at the top of the news feed means Stories are likely to be seen. The flip-side to that, however, is that as Snapchat and Instagram Stories become more used, the crowded space in both apps doesn't lend itself to scrolling beyond the first few visible.

Also, although content in Stories can have a low quality threshold, I still feel there needs to be a high relevance threshold before sharing content. What you add to your Story should add value to your narrative and not slip into just talking about yourself.

I'd love to know if your organisation has embraced Snapchat or Instagram Stories. Let me know in the comments below, or you can catch me on Twitter, Instagram, Snapchat or Facebook Messenger.

Albert Freeman is corporate communications and marketing officer (digital communications) at Bradford Citry Council.

Picture credit: Flickr / National Library of Ireland

Print Friendly and PDF
In digital + social Tags snapchat, instagram, snapchat or instagram which is best?
← A snazzy checklist and six quick tips to turbo-charge your LinkedIn profilea valedictory goodbye to local government →
comms files promo block.jpg
image.jpg

sign up to receive our new e-mag

great articles and excellent resources keeping you up-to-date with the latest in the world of creative communications. straight in your inbox. on the regular.

comms2point0 will *always* respect your privacy.

Thank you!

Want to write a post for comms2point0?  Email us a brief outline of your post idea or specialist subject and we'll be in touch!

Name *

Thank you, Darren or Dan will be in touch with you soon!

latest jobs...

Featured
May 12, 2025
senior communications officer, blackburn with darwen
May 12, 2025
Read More →
May 12, 2025
May 10, 2025
corporate communications manager - marketing, essex county fire and rescue service
May 10, 2025
Read More →
May 10, 2025

• sign up to receive the comms2point0 e-mag •

comms2point0.co.uk is a free shared learning space, created by – and written for – creative communications professionals.  Home to fresh comment, informed opinion, in depth analysis and expert feature articles, comms2point.co.uk inspires and supports communications professionals in the UK, Europe and beyond.

©2011 - 2025 Darren Caveney, Creative Communicators Ltd.

Related Posts Plugin for WordPress, Blogger...